A CHRISTMAS INVITATION RETRACTED......

My daughters (20 and 23) have just come up with a situation involving their father and his new girlfriend of 9 months for which they are asking my advice, and I in turn, could use some expert advice from you. I came across your website on the internet today.

My daughter's father and I have been divorced for 19 years. He remarried once but lost that wife to cancer 4 years ago. Last February, he began dating a woman in her mid to late 50's that also has 2 grown daughters. Within a few months, he and his girlfriend purchased a home and moved in together. He and I have maintained a fairly good relationship all these years and have attended school
graduations, etc. together. The new partner does not believe that he and I should have any contact or relationship and has voiced some unpleasant opinions over the past few months, but my daughters have continued to visit and usually make the best of the time together. Now that Christmas is here, everything has blown up. Here's the situation; the girls said yes to their dad’s invitation for Christmas day a few months ago, on the understanding that their grandparents and siblings/cousins would all be in attendance, just like the past 19 years. His new partner did not want to entertain his whole family and hence only invited his parents and our daughters.
My children then said that they would enjoy coming up in the morning to open gifts and have brunch, however, their only chance to see the rest of their dad's family for the next 8 months would be for dinner and therefore, they would move on there mid-afternoon. A very nasty phone call ensued last evening, yelling blame and insulting our daughters, claiming selfishness and not 'thinking about 'her'
feelings' - the girlfriend, that is (from both their dad and his new girlfriend). My youngest (21) remained extremely calm and mature - until her dad refused to see the other side and retracted the invitation to come for any part of the day, saying that if
they ‘wouldn't come for dinner, they weren't welcome any part of the day.’ He further stated that he'd 'drop their presents off at the front door' of our home. Needless to say, this has caused a great amount of stress and upset in our home and I'm wondering what your thoughts and/or advice might be. The girls now do not want to go to their dad's, nor do they think it's wise to go visit grandparents, just to avoid any further anger and conflict.

I really appreciate your time and thoughts, thank you.

( categories: Dear Everyone )
Submitted by emily on Tue, 2006-12-19 12:43.

I'd also add that, from my unscientific observations of fathers with new wives / girlfriends, it seems that they do sometimes find themselves feeling trapped and caught in the middle - pulled between the new squeeze, their children, and you the other parent. it seems to me that the father generally goes with the line of least resistance and that's to support the one they live with and who'll be bending their ear and refusing to iron their shirts etc if they don't support them. I can see how it happens and I can see how torn the father feels, but he's probably more worried about keeping new squeeze happy as he'll be less secure in his love for her than in the all-consuming, non-negotiable love he has for his children which as a parent we know we will always feel and it doesn;t feel at risk. As a result he decides to reinforce his committment to Audrey rather than to his children as he has assumed that they know he loves them completely and don;t need the reassurance. So if I was your daughters I'd go to Dad's for Christmas and do what 'Audrey' wants inorder to take the pressure off Dad, and un-arm Aud, giving her no ammunition to come even more between father and children.

Submitted by kate on Tue, 2006-12-19 11:21.

Hi

We have had a mull and a chat and these are our thoughts for what they are worth .

There has clearly been some break down of communication here about what everyone was hoping wanting and expecting for Christmas Day and now it seems nobody is getting what they want !!!! And now it has all got out of hand and I would guess EVERYONE is upset and stressed.

Flipping Nora Christmas can be a shocker , so many vibes , expectations and just everything.

From the perspective of you and your girls , the new girlfriend is wrong to say that there is no need for you to have a relationship with Dad . You have done so well that you must try to avoid all your good work co parenting for so long to collapse now. The girls still need both of you , you still have weddings christening and grandchildren to enjoy together. Maybe new girlfriend and her ex do not have such a good relationship but whatever do not get drawn into unpleasant convestations , who know what is going on with her ??? though it does feel as though she is threatened to some extenty by your arrangement . What ever that is her problem that you mustn't let affect your gang .

She sounds a bit of a permenant fixture , so I think that this situation needs you and the girls to be big. Retracting invitations , leaving presents on the door step !!!! Stop this right now and I am afraid it is up to you three to take a grip and diffuse the situation do not provide any ammunition and make sure that relationship with Dad does not spiral out of control .

So as they are not going to see the extended family anyway we think they should contact Dad and say something along the lines of:

Sorry hadn't realised etc etc don't want to hurt Audrey's ( thats what I imagine her name to be ) feelings so will indeed be there for the lot. They want to forget the bad vibes and start all over again with the plans , obvioulsy all got wrong end of stick

Then go girls - do not drink too much !!!!!!! stay calm , mature and know that you have done a good thing !!! and in the back of your mind plan a really good christmas for next year !!!!!! or a really good new years eve party or something to help you through what will probably be a tricky day , but will be better than sitting at home feeling bad .

Do let us know and be brave !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!